House Music Daily - News and New Music from the publishers of 5 Magazine
13Dec2009
Hi-Fi Hell: CDs vs. Vinyl vs. MP3 All Over Again

Imported beer tastes better. Microbrews, as a rule, taste better. Yet Budweiser and Miller sell billions of bottles a year and it's not because they brainwash us by carpet-bombing advertising all over the place, but because millions and millions of people (yeah, I know!) like them.

The argument of hi-fi vs. lo-fi has been around for at least 25 years - really since CDs began replacing vinyl as the packaging of choice among consumers. And actually, there isn't an argument at all: hi-fi is better. Many DJs I've spoken to feel almost as if they've been railroaded into a vinyl-less world, and it's true - if you want to stay up on music these days, you're going to have to deal with MP3s even if you think they are (and they are!) clearly inferior.

Now we're starting to see a new phenomenon. People brought up listening to MP3s, whose primary stereo is an iPod and computer, actually prefer the sound of lo-fi over hi-fi... when they can even tell the difference. From PC World:

The Professor found over time the preference was for MP3 encoded songs, with those listening failing to establish any loss in audio quality normally associated with compressed digital music.

"I found not only that MP3s were not thought of as low quality, but over time there was a rise in preference for MP3s," said the Professor who suggests the digitising process leaves music with a 'sizzle' or a metallic sound.

As with a previous generation's debate over the pros and cons of vinyl and CD, the study suggests young ears at least prefer the tinnier and flatter sound of some digital music over CDs and vinyl.

This of course goes hand-in-hand with the fact that more music is being produced to sound better through crappy speakers - to say nothing of the proliferation of Auto-tune which makes just about everything on radio sound like a Sprite commercial with rockin' guitars and multicultural yet inoffensive beautiful people partying on the beach.

Two years ago, Rolling Stone proclaimed the death of high fidelity, and it's pretty much true. Budweiser, pisswater that it is, is good enough for most, like it or not.


posted dec 13 by terry matthew in news, hi-fi wars

 

The user box is unsupported by your browser.

 
 
 
tags

News | New Releases | On The Road | Advertise | Network | Contact | Mailing List | Newsletters | RSS Feeds | Privacy Policy
HouseMusicDaily.com is powered by 5 Magazine. Copyright 2009 Fivestar Boogie Productions, all rights reserved.